Articles Posted in Construction Defects

Published on:

blue shield.jpgThe California Supreme Court issued an important decision about the duty to indemnify and defend arising out of a construction contract. In Crawford v. Weather Shield, (decided 7/2008) Weather Shield (WS) manufactured and supplied windows on a large residential construction project to developer / general contractor, J.M. Peters (JMP).

The subcontract between WS and JMP provided two important and distinct rights, indemnity and defense. WS owed JMP indemnity that obligated it to repay JMP if WS’s work was defective. WS also owed JMP a defense against lawsuits “founded upon…[a] claim of such damage…growing out of the execution of [WS’s] work.”

The homeowners in a large residential project sued JMP, alleging among other things, defects in the design, manufacture, and installation of the windows. Thus, as the window manufacturer and supplier, WS’s work was directly implicated in the homeowners’ complaint. JMP cross-complained against and tendered its defense and indemnity to WS.

WS refused to defend or indemnify JMP. WS contended that its windows were not defective and therefore it did not owe JMP a duty to defend it in the underlying lawsuit. After some of the parties settled, the remainder of the case went to trial.
Continue reading →